≡ Menu

Homemade “Oreos” – Double Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

This post may include affiliate links, which means I may make a commission on purchases made through these links at no additional cost to you. 

One measure of recipe success for me is how hard I have to fight to keep enough of the finished product around to photograph. If I have to battle to even get pictures of something before it’s all gone, I know it’s a tasty recipe!

These homemade Oreo cookies were being stolen right off the ‘set!’ I cut mine into hearts because Valentine’s Day is in a couple of weeks, but you can cut them into any shape, including simple rounds. They’re easy to make, but the cream filling does take a few hours to set up so you need to plan at least a little in advance.

I hope you enjoy this recipe for double chocolate sandwich cookies!

double chocolate sandwich cookies - homemade oreos recipe

My favorite part about the white chocolate cream filling for this recipe is that it doesn’t have any vegetable shortening, but it is stiff enough not to ooze out of the cookies. I try to avoid making icing or filling with vegetable shortening when I can because I can always taste it. Maybe it’s just my imagination, but I always think that slightly odd flavor and slick texture are lurking right behind whatever flavors I do want. This simple filling only needs white chocolate, cream, and a dash of vanilla extract, so it’s delicious and easy to make!

I included a tablespoon of actual espresso in the cookie dough to enrich the chocolate flavor. We make espresso every morning because Papi Chulo is Cuban and that’s the only coffee he drinks, but you could use a tablespoon of regular coffee or just leave it out, entirely.

Like I said above, you can make these cookies in any shape you’d like. You can even roll the dough into logs instead of flattening it with a rolling pin and simply cut it into slices for super easy, no cookie cutter required cookies.

When you go to add the filling between cookies, it works best if you heap a mound in the middle of a cookie instead of spreading it out like I did in the photo below. This allows you to have more filling and it spreads out easily when you press the top cookie in place.

filling homemade oreos

Of course, if a few of the cookies never make it to the filling part, I won’t blame you! Go ahead and try one early.

chocolate heart cookies

No matter how many cookies make it to the sandwich stage, these cookies are sure to be a hit.

With my cookie cutter, this recipe made about a dozen sandwich cookies. They keep fairly well for at least a few days – I don’t think any of them made it past the fourth day without being eaten, though! You can also wrap the cooled cookies in aluminum foil and place them in an air tight container to freeze them for later. Just make sure to freeze them in the ‘cookie’ stage, rather than the ‘sandwich cookie’ stage!

homemade oreos with cream filling

I think these would make super sweet edible Valentine’s, but you can just cut them out in rounds for a delicious treat any time of year. Of course, you could also flavor or color the cream filling for added holiday flair! I recommend using gel extracts like AmeriColor for high-quality results.

If you’re looking for a nice set of heart cookie cutters, I highly recommend these from Fox Run. You can’t tell from the Amazon photo, but they come in a cute case and they’ve held up to a lot of abuse!

double chocolate homemade Oreos

If you’re looking for more heart-shaped treats for Valentine’s Day:

I used the same set of cookie cutters with both of these recipes!

Greek yogurt “Graham” crackers

homemade Graham crackers with Greek yogurt

Egg-free funnel cakes

egg and dairy free funnel cake recipe

And some heart templates with free printable Valentines!

Loads of free printable heart templates for Valentines Day

I hope you enjoy these double chocolate homemade Oreos! Thanks for stopping in and a I look forward to seeing you again soon!

Double Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

watercolor luna moth with crystals and the text "Natasha" of The Artisan Life

{ 8 comments… add one }
  • Rebecca @ Dorm Room Baker February 1, 2014, 20:06

    My boyfriend loves Oreos, but I hate the artificial ingredients and preservatives in them so this seems like the perfect Valentine’s Day compromise! Besides, anything adorable, heart shaped, and chocolatey definitely has my approval.

    • natashalh February 2, 2014, 07:17

      I hear you on not liking all the weird ingredients! Things I can’t pronounce are a major pet peeve of mine. I’ll go to a lot of trouble to make something myself instead of buying it from the store to get rid of all the additives! Thanks so much for stopping by!

  • Bianca @ Confessions of a Chocoholic February 1, 2014, 18:32

    I saw your link on Saturday Night Fever tonight and just had to click – these look perfect! I’ve never attempted making my own oreos before but I might just try my hand with these. And the heart shape is too cute!

    • natashalh February 1, 2014, 19:02

      They’re so super delicious! I’ll never be tempted to buy them at the store again. Thanks for stopping by!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.